Key Takeaways
- Chairside oral splints achieved sub-2 mm navigational accuracy across all cranial regions up to a target distance of 152 mm, with viscerocranial deviation of 0.90 ± 0.27 mm (maxillary splint) and 0.90 ± 0.53 mm (vestibular splint).
- Accuracy degraded predictably with distance from the splint reference point: skull base 1.10 ± 0.39 mm and neurocranium 1.45 ± 0.59 mm for the maxillary splint, remaining clinically acceptable throughout.
- No statistically significant difference was found between maxillary and vestibular splint designs regarding precision (p < 0.048 threshold applied across regional comparisons).
- Accuracy persisted after ten removal-and-reattachment cycles, confirming reproducibility for multi-stage or re-docking procedures without re-registration.
Clinical Context
Frameless stereotactic navigation has become indispensable in anatomically complex ENT, skull base, and maxillofacial procedures, where precise correlation between preoperative imaging and intraoperative anatomy determines surgical safety and margin control. Conventional registration relies on bone-implanted fiducial markers—the accepted gold standard at approximately 0.33 ± 0.26 mm accuracy—but these require an additional invasive procedure, add patient morbidity, and delay navigation availability in acutely traumatized patients.
Non-invasive alternatives each carry trade-offs: skin-adhesive markers suffer from soft-tissue resilience and turgor changes under general anesthesia (deviations up to 4 mm), laser surface scanning achieves only 2.4 mm at the lateral skull base, and landmark-based registration can exceed 6 mm error. Dental and occlusal structures offer a rigid, reproducible reference platform, but the distance-dependent accuracy of chairside-fabricated oral splints had not been systematically quantified against rigid bone markers.
This cadaver validation study, conducted at a high-volume tertiary referral center (NILIUSKLINIK Dortmund, affiliated with Technische Universität Dresden), tested two chairside splint designs against twenty standardized bone anchors to define the precision envelope of oral-splint-based registration for image-guided ENT and maxillofacial surgery.
Clinical Evidence & Cohort Breakdown
Study design: Dry cadaver skull armed with 20 standardized bone markers (Howmedica-Leibinger) distributed across viscerocranium, skull base, and neurocranium. Axial spiral CT (Siemens Somatom Sensation 64; 1.2 mm collimation, 1.0 mm reconstruction increment) was transferred to a Surgical Tool Navigator System (Carl Zeiss, STP4). Five maxillary splints (MaxS) and five vestibular splints (VestS) were tested, each with nine independent correlations per bone marker, immediately after fabrication (Group A) and after ten removal/reattachment cycles (Group B).
Regional accuracy comparison (mean ± SD):
| Cranial Region | Maxillary Splint (MaxS) | Vestibular Splint (VestS) | Statistical Significance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Viscerocranium | 0.90 ± 0.27 mm | 0.90 ± 0.53 mm | Not distinguishable |
| Skull base | 1.10 ± 0.39 mm | 1.20 ± 0.37 mm | Not distinguishable |
| Neurocranium | 1.45 ± 0.59 mm | 1.70 ± 0.76 mm | Not distinguishable (p < 0.048) |
Distance-dependent precision (MaxS):
| Target Landmark | Distance from Splint Center | Deviation (Mean ± SD) |
|---|---|---|
| Palatal area (nearby) | ~4.3 cm | 0.71 ± 0.12 mm |
| Mastoid (mid-range) | 14.7 cm | < 2 mm threshold maintained |
| Occipital bone (maximum) | 24.5 cm | 1.85 ± 0.46 mm |
Both splint types maintained < 2 mm accuracy up to a 152 mm linear distance from the subnasal splint focal point—comparable to the distance from the splint center to the mastoid—covering the entire viscerocranium and central skull base target envelope relevant to most ENT and maxillofacial procedures. Accuracy remained stable after ten reattachment cycles, with Group B values closely tracking Group A.
Intraoperative IONM Protocol & Technical Pearls
Note: While this protocol addresses navigational registration rather than neurophysiological monitoring, the following step-by-step guidance translates the study methodology into actionable OR workflow for image-guided ENT/maxillofacial surgery.
-
Preoperative CT acquisition: Obtain axial spiral CT with slice collimation ≤ 1.2 mm and reconstruction increment of 1.0 mm (kernel H60s; effective dose approximately 2.85 mSv). Thin-slice reconstruction is essential for accurate fiducial localization and three-dimensional surface rendering.
-
Splint fabrication (chairside): For dentate patients, prepare a maxillary splint (MaxS) using a perforated impression tray (sizes BO0–BOIII) filled with A-silicone (e.g., Flexitime Monophase or Dimension Bite 60 Sec). Attach prefabricated connector sockets to the vestibular surface for standardized navigation markers, adjusting base plugs in x-, y-, and z-directions. Fix a plastic handle anteriorly to carry a subnasal marker.
-
Edentulous or anatomically compromised patients: Fabricate a vestibular splint (VestS) from light-cured synthetic material in a pacifier configuration, polymerizing one non-standard grasp and four base items labially for fiducial accommodation. Use when palatal pathology (e.g., bleeding hemangiomas) or vomiting risk contraindicates a palatal-supported device.
-
Fiducial placement and registration: Mount the splint intraorally and perform CT scanning with the splint in situ. Register the splint fiducials to the imported CT dataset using the navigation system's landmark test, verifying correct patient position on the monitor at 400% magnification in multiplanar reconstruction.
-
Dynamic reference frame (DRF) setup: Firmly fasten the DRF to the head-holding device (e.g., Mayfield clamp) via an adapter, positioning the infrared localization camera approximately 2 m from the surgical field. Confirm that tripod location and head adjustment remain unchanged throughout the procedure.
-
Intraoperative verification: Periodically re-verify registration using the landmark test, particularly after any splint manipulation or patient repositioning. Anticipate distance-dependent error: targets within the viscerocranium and central skull base will demonstrate sub-1.5 mm accuracy, while far-lateral or posterior targets approach the 2 mm threshold.
-
Multi-stage procedures: The splint may be removed and reattached up to ten times without clinically meaningful loss of accuracy, supporting staged tumor resection, reconstruction, and postoperative evaluation workflows.
Clinical Implications for Surgeons & IONM Specialists
-
Non-invasive registration alternative: Chairside oral splints eliminate the need for bone-implanted fiducial screws, reducing patient morbidity and enabling immediate navigation in acutely traumatized patients who would otherwise require a separate marker-placement procedure before image-guided intervention.
-
Predictable accuracy envelope: Surgeons can anticipate sub-2 mm navigational precision for targets within 150 mm of the subnasal reference point—encompassing the maxilla, orbit, anterior skull base, and temporal bone—with accuracy degrading linearly beyond this range. For far-lateral skull base or posterior fossa targets, consider supplementing with bone-implanted markers as described in the literature (combined dental splint plus lateral orbital rim markers).
-
Design selection by anatomy: MaxS is preferred for dentate patients or those with implant-based fixed prosthetics, leveraging multiple tooth contacts and the resilient palatal median raphe for stable seating. VestS serves edentulous patients, those with palatal pathology, or dysmorphic central facial anatomy, though soft-tissue resilience in vivo (not modeled on the dry skull) may introduce additional variance requiring clinical validation.
-
Workflow integration: Chairside fabrication is feasible in the primary operative setting, supporting computer-assisted three-dimensional navigation from initial diagnosis through postoperative reconstruction assessment. The dimensional stability of A-silicones (minimum 5 years) permits delayed control imaging and longitudinal outcome evaluation.
-
Future directions: Oral splints with fiducial markers are well-positioned for integration with augmented reality and mixed-reality platforms, enabling simplified automatic matching of radiological data to real-time extraoral patient images—a capability not yet realized in current clinical practice.
Reference
Nilius M, Nilius MH. How precise are oral splints for frameless stereotaxy in guided ear, nose, throat, and maxillofacial surgery: a cadaver study. European Radiology Experimental. 2021;5:27. doi:10.1186/s41747-021-00223-3
Medical Disclaimer: This article is provided for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment recommendations. Clinical decisions regarding navigational registration techniques and surgical planning should be made by qualified healthcare professionals based on individual patient circumstances, institutional protocols, and the full body of available evidence. The accuracy data presented derive from a cadaver study and may not fully reflect in vivo performance, particularly regarding soft-tissue resilience and patient-specific anatomy.